We're rebranding and relaunching this site in November!

Learn more

Traffic VS. Conversion Rates: How To Strike The Perfect Balance

Last Updated on February 5, 2021 by Fabrizio Van Marciano

In this post, we will look at two important metrics needed for building a successful blog - traffic vs. conversions. How can you optimize for increased traffic and better conversions? Read more to find out.

If you manage a blog or website, where should you focus your marketing? Should you focus on ways to increase traffic, or should you focus on improving your conversion rate?

Well, that really depends on your goal.

If you sell digital products, then your aim would be to generate as many sales as possible, right? If you offer services online, the same thing applies; your aim would be to generate as many leads as possible.

So, what should you do - Should you try to increase traffic or improve your conversions?

This is the question that plagues many bloggers and online business owners. And also, this can be a complex question depending on the day.

Your first course of action may be to try to draw more traffic. The reason is, the more visitors you have, the more opportunities there are for conversions, right?

Well, this may or may not be true.

The problem starts to surface when you have a small niche, where your target market may consist of a few hundred thousand or less.

You can certainly reach a global market, but there are only so many prospects who would be interested in what you're selling.

What can you do? What can any of us do?

You can have both, but you may have to spend more time on your conversions.

By doing this, you are boosting the effectiveness of your traffic campaign. As a result, you have a win-win.

Traffic vs. conversions: You still need traffic?

Of course, you can't improve any conversions without first having traffic - and not any old traffic, too; you need targeted traffic.

I know, this sounds redundant, but let me explain.

Zero visitors mean no sales. Yet, not all traffic is worth your while.

Think of it this way:

You open a restaurant that specializes in sliders.

Your food is amazing, your friends and family can't get enough.

Although no one else knows about it, so you put up a large billboard along the highway.

Your sign reads, "Game of Thrones!" but then, you might get many customers thinking your establishment has something to do with the wildly popular TV program.

What happens when visitors walk in looking for some form of historical fiction only to find sliders and craft beers?

Alright, your food is delicious, and the beer is cold. Still, people did not come in for food. They then feel betrayed by your somewhat misleading billboard.

In this sense, the traffic was more hurtful than helpful.

You had visitors lined out the door, but only a few purchased your sliders.

This is probably why you should start with paying more attention to your conversion rates.

In another scenario, bringing in your target market will help you get more conversions.

If your signs have clear pictures of your gourmet sliders and crisp beers, then you might attract the right traffic that wants what you're offering, as I explained earlier, “targeted traffic”.

I know the scenario above was an extreme one. But hopefully, you get what I'm trying to say.

Traffic vs. conversions: Measuring conversion rates

To really become more accurate at conversion rate optimization, you need to understand the percentage of visits to your site that results in a lead or sale.

Basically, the conversion rate is the number of sales divided by the number of visits.

To illustrate: If your site was visited 100 times, and you received 10 sales, then you have a 10 percent conversion rate.

Many businesses would be quite happy with this rate.

To start, you need to determine how to boost your conversion rate - which, is essentially increasing your sales numbers without spending more on traffic.

Traffic vs. conversions: Update your website

Sometimes, your visitors do want what you're offering, but they just aren't enticed by your site's design or layout.

Does your website design turn off potential leads and sales?

Of course, you need to do this slowly. If you make five major changes all at once, you won't know which ones were most effective in increasing conversion rates.

Would you throw the kitchen sink in one pot and hope it comes out tasty? Of course not.

You want to try one modification at a time to see which ones work.

Here's something to take a look at:

This boutique spa increased revenue by 286% just by implementing a customer-focused site redesign.

The good news is you can stop utilizing any changes that don't work for you.

You might begin by taking a look at the keywords sending traffic your way.

If those keywords aren't causing your visitors to convert, then you might want to look into finding new keywords.

Recommended post: Learn how to find new keywords for your blog posts here.

Another option is to look at the text on your site.

The goal is to write explanations that put your potential customers at ease; in other words, “get your message across clearly.”

Also, you want to give your prospects the easiest and most direct route towards purchasing your product or service.

Furthermore, video tends to lead to higher conversion numbers. Although, it can't be just any video. It needs to be relevant to your prospects, such as a tutorial.

Here's something you might find interesting - 87% of online marketers use video content.

Traffic vs. conversions: How to strike the perfect balance!

You also want to think about buttons and color scheme.

Which buttons are receiving the most clicks? Which aren't? Not to mention, eliminate any buttons that make the buying process more difficult such as a "Reset" button.

Please, please consider removing any trendy buttons unless they serve a real purpose.

Traffic vs. conversions: Eliminate distractions

Now I know I’ve said this a hundred times already, but you might be getting the right traffic; however, your visitors are just too preoccupied to make any purchases.

Removing distractions is critical to boosting your conversion percentage.

If you have too many options and visual stimulants, your visitors will get their fill then leave.

They may not have any reason to return, as they have since purchased from your competitor. So, remove distractions, and these could be things like:

  • Links
  • Uninspiring stock images
  • Sidebars
  • Large headers
  • Unnecessary information
  • Too many product choices
  • Popups

Put yourself in the shoes of your customer. Then ask yourself;

Is there anything left that does not help your conversion rates?

When it comes to removing distractions, this case study shows how Taloon.com could increase conversions by 11.9 percent just by removing social sharing buttons.


Traffic vs. conversions: Review your year-over-year data

The point of this action is due to the fact that your traffic should be up every year.

This is especially true if you are doing the right things.

You can get concrete numbers by using the "compare dates" feature in Google AdWords. Select your time frame such as:

  • Last 30 Days
  • Last month
  • All time

You then compare it to:

  • Previous period
  • Same period last year
  • Custom

As you get better at your marketing campaigns, this should correspond to a rise in good traffic. Make use of Google Analytics features to measure the effectiveness of your marketing campaigns and ads.

You want an increase in traffic and improve average engagement time (Google Analytics). If you have low engagement time, you might place your ads on different landing pages to test which one comes up with a higher engagement time.

Once you retrieve that information, you can being testing your other ads.

Continue testing, and more testing

Part of the process that comes with getting the right traffic and increasing conversions is consistent testing.

Ask for some new ideas from your peers or employees, mentors, friends and family.

Request original thoughts that might boost both traffic and conversions. You want to be open-minded here, especially if you need the sales, which I'm pretty sure you do.

You don't have to become a mad scientist. A few tests here and there never hurt anyone.

Whenever you implement new changes, run A/B or multivariate tests. The key to optimizing conversions is a continuous set of tests.

You can test two potential headlines. Which one works better?

Another test would be two versions of your page.

How many conversions were made per page?

At any given time, you should always have at least one A/B test running on your site. It would be even better if you had several.

When your changes can backfire

We've all been here, but it is important to keep in mind that not all visits will become a conversion.

Some visitors might be there to check on the status of their order, ask a question or even look for an opportunity.

If you simply focus on conversions, you ignore other items relevant to your target market.

Moreover, when it comes to changing your site, there is a possibility it could be too engaging.

If you once only had pictures and prices of products, you might get visitors coming to your site to purchase something every month.

In an effort to boost that rate, you create a blog, videos, and add more photos to try to engage more prospects.

Now, your customers are visiting less and less because it takes them longer to find their desired product.

So, while your site is more engaging, your conversion rate has gone down.

Traffic vs. conversions: Visitor type


Since you don't want to decrease conversion rates, you might want to keep in mind that a prospect is less likely to buy than a loyal customer.

What stores do you frequent?

Are you likely to buy more depending on the offer?

Findings show that a loyal customer will not be moved as much to make a new purchase by a conversion modification.

So, it helps to break visitors up by type. This can be "loyal customers" vs. "prospects who never purchased."

Any changes you make will have a bigger impact on prospects than your current customer base.

Your prospects are still moved by perception. On the other hand, previous buyers might be compelled to purchase more based on delivery, quality, service, and more.

Get your visitors to come back

Since your visitors will not always purchase something, you want them to return to make a future order.

I know what you're thinking, “this is all too much.” It really isn't though.

Here are a few options to try:

  • Update your blog with quality and relevant content.
  • Add an interesting video.
  • Ensure your site is user-friendly and well-designed.
  • Offer an email opt-in and updates through RSS or Feedly.
  • Place specials on specific days, such as Tuesdays and Thursdays.
  • Highlight new products, features, and services.
  • Use a business name and URL that is easy to remember.
  • Ask your customers questions.
  • Share updates on social media.
  • Let them have free content to download such as tutorials.
  • Have contests regularly. Visitors will come back to see the latest contest.

Of course, you want to keep track of all your modifications and progress.

You want to see where your visitors are coming from, how many visitors you are getting, and at what stage the conversions start. Also, you want to look at the number of users and session sources in Google Analytics.

It doesn't feel like work when the sales start exploding.

There is a way to strike the perfect balance between more traffic and better conversion rates.

It comes down to bringing in the right visitors and making appropriate changes based on your A/B tests.

Don't lose focus when it comes to testing, you always have to make updates in order to get the best results year-over-year.

Tools for helping you to boost traffic and conversions to your website

  1. Thrive Suite - Powerful conversion-focused tools for building a conversion-optimized blog or website.
  2. Google Analytics - A free traffic and engagement analysis tool.
  3. Crazy Egg - A/B split testing tools for bloggers and businesses.

Over to you

What are you doing to both increase traffic and boost conversion rates to your online business? Is there a specific technique that's working for you right now? If you have any tips you'd like to share, please leave me a comment below as usual. If the comment section is closed, feel free to share this post on social media and tag me @fabriziovanmarciano

Join Over 24,500+ Subscribers

Get fresh content from Magnet4Blogging delivered straight to your inbox, spam free! Or follow us on social media.
pencilcamera-videomic linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram